Summary

The Tweed CMP covers the entire 5,000km2 cross-border Tweed catchment and includes the adjacent 120km2 Eye catchment to the north-east. Tweed Forum was formed over 30 years ago to bring together people with an interest in the Tweed catchment. It provided a space for people to discuss their aspirations for the catchment and how they might be achieved, and it was eventually decided that developing a Catchment Management Plan (CMP) was the best way to work together to achieve those aspirations. Tweed Forum listened to lots of different people and groups so that the first Tweed Catchment Management Plan reflected a wide range of viewpoints and ideas, all with the aim of improving how the Tweed, its tributaries and the landscapes they flow through were managed. The Tweed Catchment Management Plan is a single management framework for the many interacting and interdependent ecosystem services provided by the waters and wetlands of the Tweed catchment. It helps integrate different administrative, planning and regulatory systems to sustainably manage the multiple demands on the catchment for the benefit of all.

The Challenge

The Tweed Catchment Management Plan centres around seven strategic aims:

  1. Water Quality - maintain and enhance the water quality of the Tweed catchment
  2. Water Resources - manage levels and flow to the needs of the natural environment
  3. Habitats & Species - maintain and enhance the status and distribution of riverine, riparian and wetland species
  4. Physical Condition - restore modified/ impacted channels and ensure all river engineering operations respect the physical, ecological and aesthetic integrity of the river system
  5. Flood Risk Management - adopt a catchment-based approach to flood risk management which helps protect the people, property and prosperity of the Tweed catchment whilst respecting its physical, ecological and aesthetic qualities
  6. Tourism & Recreation - promote the sustainable development of river-related tourism and recreation and protect cultural heritage and landscapes
  7. CMP Delivery & Development - ensure the delivery and development of the Tweed Catchment Management Plan

Some of the challenges to implementation of the CMP included:

  • Landowner engagement and persuading farmers to lose productive ground or change the way they do things.
  • Working at a bigger scale when multiple landowners are involved, with the river acting as the boundary; moving the physical entity that acts as the property boundary is more than just a practical problem.
  • Regulation: for example, re-meandering requires consent from SEPA under the controlled activity regulations, consent from SNH due to it being a designated site, planning permission from the local authority because it is deemed an engineering operation.
  • Funding: Some of the works are expensive and often there are no bespoke funding streams.

The Solution

The plan identifies specific objectives, targets and actions, for each of the Strategic Aims:

  1. Water Quality: maintain and enhance the water quality of the Tweed catchment
  • Locate, investigate and address specific water quality problem areas within the catchment
  • Monitor, evaluate and address the impact of agriculture, forestry and plastics on water quality in the catchment
  • Minimise the impact of residential and industrial development on the water quality of the catchment
  1. Water Resources: manage levels and flow to the needs of the natural environment
  • Consider the needs of the environment alongside those of all other water users
  1. Habitats & Species: maintain and enhance the status and distribution of riverine, riparian and wetland species
  • Ensure access to data on riverine, wetland and riparian habitats and species to inform sustainable management practices
  • Promote the restoration of ecosystems, ecosystem function and ecosystem services to help mitigate, where relevant, the climate and biodiversity crises
  • Monitor and control the introduction and establishment of non-native riverine and riparian species and where appropriate control or eradicate established populations
  1. Physical Condition - restore modified/ impacted channels and ensure all river engineering operations respect the physical, ecological and aesthetic integrity of the river system
  • Improve understanding of the impact of river engineering works and seek to address degraded stretches
  1. Flood Risk Management: adopt a catchment-based approach to flood risk management which helps protect the people, property and prosperity of the Tweed catchment whilst respecting its physical, ecological and aesthetic qualities
  • Improve knowledge, understanding and awareness of flood risk management issues within the Tweed catchment
  • Encourage Sustainable Flood Management, where appropriate
  • Evaluate and address the impact of land management practices on the frequency and intensity of flood events
  1. Tourism & Recreation: promote the sustainable development of river-related tourism and recreation and protect cultural heritage and landscapes
  • Support tourism and recreation activities which promote good practice, deliver multiple benefits and do not come into conflict with other aims and objectives set out in this document
  • Promote and establish tourism and recreational activities based on the built, natural and cultural heritage of the Tweed and its tributaries

Impact

The plan is ongoing, from 2023 to 2028.

Key Learnings

  • Ongoing monitoring and review of the Tweed CMP is vital to its success . The majority of the actions cannot be set in stone: as some actions and targets are achieved, others will be changing, requiring a truly responsive and dynamic process and an adaptive management approach. Tweed Forum has carried out reviews at appropriate timescales and ensured that all partners and participants concerned with implementation activities have been involved. As part of the review process, progress towards targets/actions is monitored, priorities for action re-examined, additional actions and targets included where appropriate and key funding requirements identified.
  • There are several cross-cutting themes which influence the Tweed CMP. These cross- cutting themes, by their very nature, do not sit within a single given area of the CMP and must be woven into each and every element of the CMP and its processes. Chief amongst these themes are the need to progress actions addressing the climate and biodiversity crises, the adoption of an Ecosystem Approach (including enhanced engagement with stakeholders), the growing importance of the Natural Capital agenda and the need for a coherent land use strategy.
  • The climate crisis and its likely impacts on the freshwater environment is probably the single, most important issue for freshwater management in the UK. It is now universally recognised that building climate resilience - taking prior action to prepare habitats, species, farming and land management practices for rapid environmental change and more extreme weather events, in tandem with action to reduce levels of greenhouse gases in our atmosphere - is a key element in reducing the impacts of the climate emergency.
  • The £25+ million Destination Tweed project focuses on the development of a world-class, source-to-sea trail, but also includes a range of projects that cut across 4 of the 6 core aims of the CMP. Central to the portfolio is the theme of connectivity, and cause and effect; the project recognises that in managing an entity such as a river, there is a need to act at the catchment scale, with many of the issues connected. The project seeks to address the causes of issues, rather than just the symptoms; and to create a more sustainable and resilient landscape for the future.

Further Developments

Over the next five years, the Tweed Catchment Management Plan partners will continue working towards delivering the actions set out within the Plan.

Read More

Explore the case study in more detail (opens in a new window)

Go Back

Related Projects

Promoting Adaptation to Changing Coasts

The Promoting Adaptation to Changing Coasts (PACCo) project is an EU-funded initiative that focuses on piloting pre-emptive climate change adaptation in two estuaries...

Cardiff Greener Grangetown

The Greener Grangetown project in Cardiff utilized sustainable urban drainage systems (SuDS) to transform the urban environment...

Leaky Dams at Croft Castle

Implementing 27 leaky dams on the Ridgemoor Brook at Croft Castle has improved the water quality in the pools further downstream...

Alma Road Rain Gardens

The Alma Road Rain Gardens project in London is a compelling example of climate adaptation through implementing sustainable rain gardens to address...

London's Living Roofs Programme

The London Living Roofs programme was initiated by the Greater London Authority (GLA) to promote and support the widespread adoption of green roofs across the city.

Improving Energy Efficiency in Historic Cornish Buildings

Cornwall Council Historic Environment Service have produced a guide to maintaining, repairing and restoring historic buildings, while implementing...